If you’re in West Chester and haven’t yet tried a hoagie from Patelmo’s Pizzeria, consider this your friendly nudge. While they’ve already earned a solid reputation for their brick oven pizza, their hoagies are the kind of hidden gems locals rave about. Whether you’re into cold cuts, melty cheese, or savory chicken, there’s a sandwich West Chester flavor with your name on it.
Here’s everything you need to know before diving into the hoagie heaven that is Patelmo’s.
What Makes Patelmo’s Hoagies West Chester’s Favorite?
Let’s start with what really makes a hoagie great: the ingredients.
Patelmo’s Pizzeria doesn’t cut corners. Every hoagie starts with fresh-baked bread—available in 6″, 9″, or a giant 18″ Italian loaf, with optional seeded crust. From there, it’s stacked with premium meats, hand-sliced cheeses, and fresh produce that tastes like it was picked just for your sandwich.
Here’s what sets them apart:
- Premium deli meats like prosciutto, pepper ham, turkey, and roast pork
- Imported and local cheeses, including sharp provolone, mozzarella, and a 4-cheese blend
- Fresh veggies like crispy lettuce, juicy tomatoes, arugula, and roasted red peppers
- Signature sauces like basil aioli and classic marinara that elevate every bite
Cold Sandwich West Chester Favorites You Need to Try
Prefer your hoagies chilled and refreshing? Patelmo’s cold sandwich lineup is stacked.
Popular Cold Hoagies Include:
- The Italian – A traditional favorite with ham, capicola, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and oil
- Caprese Sub – Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, arugula, and basil aioli
- Turkey Club – Oven-roasted turkey, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and creamy mayo
- Roast Beef – Thin-sliced beef layered with sharp provolone and zesty horseradish mayo
Don’t forget—you can customize your sandwich with extras like olive salad, whole pickles, or your choice of bread (white, wheat, rye, multigrain, or a kaiser roll).
Best Hot Sandwich West Chester Has to Offer
Some days just call for something warm, cheesy, and filling—and Patelmo’s Pizzeria delivers.
Fan-Favorite Hot Hoagies:
- Chicken Cutlet with Sharp Provolone – Golden-brown chicken cutlet with a satisfying crunch, smothered in melted sharp provolone and sweet roasted peppers
- Buffalo Chicken Hoagie – Crispy tenders tossed in buffalo sauce, with tangy blue cheese dressing
- Chicken or Veal Parm – Smothered in marinara, topped with melted mozzarella and Pecorino Romano
- Roasted Pork with Broccoli Rabe – A nod to Philly tradition, with bold, garlicky flavor and melty provolone
Each hot hoagie is made to order and served piping hot, with portions that make leftovers a real possibility.
Sandwich West Chester Creations You’ve Never Tried Before
Looking for something different? Patelmo’s has that covered too.
- Seafood Salad Hoagie – Cool, creamy seafood salad packed with flavor
- Veggie Hoagie with Roasted Peppers & Sharp Cheese – A vegetarian dream with depth and balance
- Italian Tuna with Cheese – Savory, oil-packed tuna with crisp toppings and your choice of cheese
And yes—you can add extras like roasted peppers, sharp provolone, or even macaroni salad on the side. There’s no wrong choice here.
And if you’re throwing a party, hosting game night, or planning an office lunch, Patelmo’s hoagie trays are a total win. They’re generous, delicious, and completely stress-free.
- Mixed Luncheon Meats Hoagie Tray – A crowd-pleasing mix of cold cuts
- Chicken Cutlet Tray – Served with roasted red peppers and sharp provolone
These trays come loaded and ready to go—just unwrap and enjoy.
Craving Hoagies West Chester Style? Here’s Where to Go
By now, you’re probably thinking about your next meal—and it should definitely be from Patelmo’s Pizzeria. Whether you’re in the mood for a hot Chicken Parm or a cool Caprese sub, there’s a sandwich West Chester foodies can all agree is worth the trip.
Stop by, grab a hoagie, and see what all the buzz is about. Better yet, bring a friend and try a few. With a menu this good, you’ll want to come back again and again.
Order online from Patelmo’s Pizzeria or visit their restaurant in West Chester to enjoy your favorite hoagie!
